WTP 2018-01-25

WTP Development Status Meeting

Remember, any committer can add an agenda item. Typically, short announcements or news items go in the "Announcements" section at the beginning. Longer items or issues requiring discussion should go in the "Other business" section at end.

WTP Calendar

WTP Calendar Sync

For overall Oxygen dates, see the Simultaneous Release Calendar

Main Agenda Items

• Migration of Eclipse Data Tools into Eclipse Tools?
  • Though previously it was discussed that DTP could move back into WTP, it's been decided it will move to Tools instead. Work in progress here:
    • https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=510140

• Sanity check the tags/branches used to build R3_9_maintenance branch
  • See https://git.eclipse.org/c/webtools/webtools.releng.aggregator.git/tree/scripts/repositories.txt?h=R3_9_maintenance
    • SSE and JSDT: correct tags? Why not branches?
    • Dali, ejb, javaee.tests, jsf, jsf.docs, releng, servertools.docs, servertools.tests, sourceediting.x*, webservices: why master?

• What's the deal with the WTP calendar?
  • It shows biweekly PMC calls, but nothing has been posted to https://www.eclipse.org/webtools/development/index_pmc_call_notes.php since June 13, 2017.
  • It shows NO dev calls, only biweekly smoke tests. Are we no longer doing dev calls?
  • If you need someone to update calendars and wiki pages, please give Nick Boldt access and I'll do it. :)

Release news/planning

• Follow-on releases no longer called "Service Release" - now indicated by number (Oxygen.2)
  • More flexibility for new features in these releases.
  • WTP has been flexible for new enhancements in SR releases, but announced and PMC voted as appropriate

• Oxygen release planning

WTP 3.9.3: Oxygen.3

• R3_9_maintenance is open once again for new contributions. Latest repos file is here:

http://git.eclipse.org/c/webtools/webtools.releng.aggregator.git/tree/scripts/repositories.txt?h=R3_9_maintenance

• If you see something wrong, please submit a gerrit request to get it fixed.

3.9.3 Schedule

1/25 3.9.3 Maintenance build

2/8 WTP Oxygen.3 RC1 (begin PMC +1 after declare)

2/15 WTP Oxygen.3 RC2 (still PMC +1)

2/22 WTP Oxygen.3 RC3 (begin PMC +2 after declare)

3/01 WTP Oxygen.3 RC4 (begin PMC +3 after declare)

3.9.3 Builds

• Smoke Test

WTP 3.10.0: Photon

• Project plans were due some time ago (M4)
• Photon Schedule

3.10.0 Schedule

1/25 WTP Photon M5

2/8 3.10.0 Integration build

3.10.0 Builds

• Smoke Test

WTP 3.10.0: Repo Re-org And Releng Redux

• Overall repo merge issue: https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=525342

• Current repos:
  • https://wiki.eclipse.org/WTP_Gerrit_Access#Clone_a_repository_for_development (authenticated clone for use with Gerrit)
  • https://wiki.eclipse.org/WTP_Git_Workflows#Commandline_git_.28anonymous_read-only.29 (anon read-only clone)
  • https://wiki.eclipse.org/WTP_Git_Workflows#Clone_a_repo (online browsing)

Colour Legend:

• STATUS: GREEN
  •  : nothing blocking, no stalled gerrit requests, good communication between releng and project committers/lead, ready to be aggregated
• STATUS: BLUE
  •  : nothing blocking, no stalled gerrit requests, good communication between releng and project committers/lead, some (optional?) work to be done
• STATUS: ORANGE
  •  : some blockers or stalled gerrit requests, delayed/difficult communication between releng and project committers/lead, dependency problems (-Pintegration workaround)
• STATUS: RED
  •  : unstarted work, work blocked by upstream, blockers or stalled gerrit requests, delayed/difficult/no communication between releng and project committers/lead, circular dependencies to the resolved

Gerrit requests

The following requests have stalled with no response, or have been reviewed but not merged. Help me help you!

• [ws] https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/c/71088/ - Contribute Jax-RS project detection to Smart Importer (needs refactoring - pending)

• [ws] https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/c/115660/ - Bug 528792 WS will soon depend on jsf and javaee, so add deps to upstream repos
• [ws] https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=528792#c17 - Find a new home for [javaee] enterprise and web features which require webservices

• [servertools] https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/c/115400/ - fix typos and use string replacements for working tests; disable broken test for deprecated site.xml update sites, as no longer working

• [javaee] https://git.eclipse.org/r/116062 - 528792 remove references to the features that moved to webservices - not yet merged, requires kchong to do ws first

• [sse] https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/c/115998/ - remove unused @buildversionid@; add org.eclipse.jst.jsp.core.tests so it can be seen by downstream repos

Project Summary

common

Project	Status	Browse Git	p2 Repo	Tests	Pending Changes	Gerrit Builds	Clone
common	green	git gitiles	lastSuccessfulBuild	232 tests	gerrit	master	git clone ssh://${GITUSER}@git.eclipse.org:29418/webtools-common/webtools.common.git

• TODO:
  • [AI: Nick] ensure source bundles/features correctly produced

servertools

Project	Status	Browse Git	p2 Repo	Tests	Pending Changes	Gerrit Builds	Clone
servertools	green	git gitiles	lastSuccessfulBuild	235 tests	gerrit	master	git clone ssh://${GITUSER}@git.eclipse.org:29418/servertools/webtools.servertools.git

• TODO:
  • [AI: Nick] cleanup sourceTemplate folders, ensure source bundles/features correctly produced
  • Disable broken servertools integration test so that gerrit reviews pass: https://git.eclipse.org/r/115400

jsdt

Project	Status	Browse Git	p2 Repo	Tests	Pending Changes	Gerrit Builds	Clone
jsdt	green	git gitiles	lastSuccessfulBuild	1467 (3 skip) tests	gerrit	master	git clone ssh://${GITUSER}@git.eclipse.org:29418/jsdt/webtools.jsdt.git

• TODO:
  • [AI: Nick] cleanup sourceTemplate folders, ensure source bundles/features correctly produced

sourcediting

Project	Status	Browse Git	p2 Repo	Tests	Pending Changes	Gerrit Builds	Clone
sourceediting	green	git gitiles	lastSuccessfulBuild	10,880) tests	gerrit	master	git clone ssh://${GITUSER}@git.eclipse.org:29418/sourceediting/webtools.sourceediting.git

• TODO:
  • [AI:Nick] purge generated files / fix .gitignores, cleanup sourceTemplate folders

jeetools

Project	Status	Browse Git	p2 Repo	Tests	Pending Changes	Gerrit Builds	Clone
javaee	red	git gitiles	lastSuccessfulBuild	3 tests	gerrit	master	git clone ssh://${GITUSER}@git.eclipse.org:29418/jeetools/webtools.javaee.git

• webtools-javaee-gerrit_R3_9
• Blocked? YES - need to move cross-repo features downstream to webservices or releng.aggregator.
• TODO:
  • https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=528792 - Find a new home for [javaee] enterprise and web features which require webservices
    • [AI: Rob] 11 features need to be moved downstream to webservices: Rob has a script for this: https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=528792#c9
    • [AI: Chuck, Carl, Elson, Keith, etc.] review the proposed change and decide who will run it. Needs webmaster assistance to disable Gerrit review to achieve this.
  • [AI: Nick] verify after moving out features and decoupling from WS, we can build w/o `-P integration` workaround
  • [AI: Nick] cleanup sourceTemplate folders

dali

Project	Status	Browse Git	p2 Repo	Tests	Pending Changes	Gerrit Builds	Clone
dali	green	git gitiles	lastSuccessfulBuild	4697 tests	gerrit	master	git clone ssh://${GITUSER}@git.eclipse.org:29418/dali/webtools.dali.git

• TODO:
  • cleanup sourceTemplate folders

jsf

Project	Status	Browse Git	p2 Repo	Tests	Pending Changes	Gerrit Builds	Clone
jsf	green	git gitiles	lastSuccessfulBuild	675 tests	gerrit	master	git clone ssh://${GITUSER}@git.eclipse.org:29418/jsf/webtools.jsf.git

• TODO:
  • cleanup sourceTemplate folders

webservices

Project	Status	Browse Git	p2 Repo	Tests	Pending Changes	Gerrit Builds	Clone
webservices	orange	git gitiles	lastSuccessfulBuild	339 tests	gerrit	master	git clone ssh://${GITUSER}@git.eclipse.org:29418/webservices/webtools.webservices.git

• TODO:
  • [AI: Rob] move is scripted: https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=528792#c9
    • [AI: Chuck, Carl, Elson, Keith, etc.] review the proposed change and decide who will run it. Needs webmaster assistance to disable Gerrit review to achieve this.
  • [AI: Rob/Nick] script merge, attach script/repo to https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=530261
  • [AI: Nick] update releng.aggregator after merge is complete to remove refs to obsolete repos
  • remove -Pintegration flag from job so it depends ONLY on upstream CI builds
  • cleanup sourceTemplate folders

releng.aggregator

• Figure out how to collect all the test results into the releng.aggregator job, or a new JUnit collection job
• Figure out why org.eclipse.wst.server.core is not present in the aggregator builds, but IS present in the servertools CI builds
  • what other missing plugins/features are there?

Jenkins migration

• https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=527520 Migrate from HIPP to JIPP

Bug and Feature Highlights

Focus on Quality

• Improve:

• Major or higher severity bugs by project (This week - 182)

• Targeted to Future (candidates for severity downgrade?) (Total - 73)

• Triage:

• Untargeted bugs and enhancements with patches attached over 7 days old (This week - 70)
• Untargeted severity "Major" and higher bugs opened over 7 days ago (This week - 105)
• Options:

• Target to a specific release or "future" if planning to fix but not in the next release
• Adjust severity as appropriate

Release Bug Review

Oxygen.2 targeted bugs

Blockers, Hot-Bugs, Hot-Features

Blocker and Critical

Hotbugs

Hotfeatures

Hotfeatures - triaged with helpwanted

Project scrum section

• Each project answers
  • What are you working on?
  • What are you planning for next week?

Server Tools

• This week: bug 527813
• Next week: TBD

WTP Source Editing

• This week:
  • Build breakage from usage of internal HTMLPrinter, since resolved
  • 530148 - Resolved

• Next week:
  • 519189 - Adoption of 1.8 as BREE (mostly)

Web Services Tools

• This week: 530261
• Resolved recently: 519793

Other business - Long term tracking items

• Automated Error report logging - Now in JavaEE EPP
  • We need more WTP participation (triaging / fixing / coordinating / watching)
  • Dashboard
  • Incident reports
  • JST Problems Query

• CBI -
  • All open CBI bugs
  • Eclipse Common Build Infrastructure home

References

Also, see

• WTP Git Usage/Discussion page

• New Help for Old Friends

• Provisional API

Luna release retrospective

Standard Format Plans

how/when to branch code?

IP Logs selector

WTP Who's Who

See also the WTP Meeting Archive-Reference Page.